Update Woes

Update Woes

My phone is a Nexus 5X, I bought it on July 21st, 2016 - that's 3 and a half years ago. According to GSMArena it came out in October 2015, so it wasn't exactly brand new - but it was affordable and it was the best phone I ever had. I had (and have) no plans of replacing it, but Google stopped shipping security updates in December 2018, and I somehow missed this and was a little shocked when I noticed a few weeks ago - and I'm on a kind of ancient version of Android 8.1.

So I had the plan to install LineageOS because I had heard good things about it, the device seems to be supported.

So last Saturday I pulled the plug. The last time I had put a ROM on a mobile phone was probably in 2016, maybe 2017.

The installation instructions were straightforward.

  • boot into bootloader
  • unlock bootloader
  • flash recovery
  • boot into recovery
  • wipe phone
  • sideload the OS
  • add Google stuff
  • reboot

All this worked flawlessly and close to midnight on Saturday I had a phone with a new OS, still 8.1. - but built in 2020 and not in 2018.

I was a little surprised I could just restore from (Google Cloud-) backup, but it went fine and so I went to sleep at some point.

I got up on Sunday, the phone was charging overnight and unplugged it around noon and let it sit on my desk. In the evening I had a look at it and it had gone dark. Weird. So I started it and that's where the fun part of the story begins. It was stuck in a boot loop. Great. Couldn't even get into recovery, no matter what I tried.

So I didn't try too hard to solve it any further and did what everyone would do on such an occasion. Find out where the project IRC channel is and ask there. Didn't get answer in the morning but it was kinda quiet. So I asked again in the evening and got some hints, but nothing that made me go "yay, solved" instantly. Meanwhile after the phone being unplugged for hours I actually managed to get it to boot once, but it went out after like 10 minutes again, just when I had stopped looking at it.

The final thing I tried was flashing TWRP-3.3.0 instead of TWRP-3.3.1, but I don't really see how the recovery would influence anything, but as I couldn't boot into the recovery I had flashed I wanted to try this first.

Intermission: The Nexus 5X is a little infamous for being stuck with a boot loop, many people have experienced that - I personally know two people. One had it soon enough to just get LG to replace the phone. So one of the interesting links was this one about boot loops. I did find it kind of unlikely though that after 3.5 years of daily use it would just get this issue 16h after I had flashed another OS. Weird coincidence.

Some reasearch also resulted in some people saying that they did the ghetto reflow version that's been around since at least the XBox 360 days - take out the board and put it in the oven for 5-10 minutes at 200°. I had wanted to try that with my 360 when it was locking up while playing Rock Band a lot, but I never did it. So with no high hopes to ever fix the phone I did just that.

Disassembled it, took the board out (was surprisingly easy) and baked it for 6 minutes at 200°. Let it cool for 10 minutes and what can I say? Plugged it in, phone booted up just fine (albeit with an empty battery) and it's been running for roughly 24h now. The camera works and I'm a bit wary of surprises but it seems good.

I have a second Nexus 5X here that's as old and it doesn't recognize any SIM cards anymore. Now that I know it can be easily disassembled I'm inclined to do that in the near future and investigate if I can somehow see a mechanical problems and maybe properly touch of on the solder of the SIM slot parts. Or just get to baking again. Wouldn't hurt to have a working backup solution - I don't see a compelling reason to buy another 250 EUR phone when this one works just fine - if only it weren't for lack of updates...

Thanks to #lineageos on Freenode for help and emotional support :)